Aquaponic Gardening

A Community and Forum For Aquaponic Gardeners

How and for what purpose could you use perlite or vermiculite? Since these growing mediums are cheaper than hydroton and take the guess work out of buying gravel (bring some vinegar and baking soda) . Also since many people on this forum are former hydroponic growers (just harvested some lettuce today) they probably have extra perlite--I certainly do. I've heard since perlite isn't necessarily good for your lungs or fishes gills that it's not a preferred media, but root vegetables are suited to perlite mediums--though hydroton works well too. So, to boil down my question see my first sentence. 

Views: 823

Replies to This Discussion

Perlite is really light and fragile and it floats and depending on the size of it you might really cures yourself if you let it into your system.

 

I wouldn't personally use it in a normal gravel bed situation. 

 

Maybe perhaps in a hanging basket with dribble irrigation provided you are not worried about it affecting the fish's gills.

 

I use good old heavy gravel.

("depending on the size") What size could be appropriate?
The biggest stuff you can find like 1/2"  and even then, most people will warn strongly against it.
Ok, so gravel is really the universal medium.
gravel that doesn't affect pH, lava rock, or expanded clay or expanded slate, or expanded shale.
How about perlite for about the first 10" or bottom 10" and cover it with lava or pea gravel?

Well I imagine that after your first couple harvesting of root-balls and re-planting, the perlite and gravel will just be pretty mixed together. I don't know if you've ever worked with perlite before...but it does seem to tend to break down, especially when exposed to excess air and lights. Keeping it in the bottom 10" long term might be tough without some sort of barrier screen. But I imagine such a screen would become a clogged up anaerobic mess right quick...

Besides, perlite unlike gravel, hydroton, lava rock etc...has no cation exchange capacity as far as I know...which probably doesn't mean squat in a hydro system proper, but certainly might in the low (relatively speaking) nutrient concentration environment of an AP system. (Though this fact probably isn't the deal breaker, but still...)

Jeremy K said:

How about perlite for about the first 10" or bottom 10" and cover it with lava or pea gravel?

I ran out of perlite a few months ago. I'm as surprised as you are.

I've used both perlite and vermiculite/ gravel/hydroton layers. Other than worrying about my fish health I have had reasonably good luck with both. I am going to go with expanded shale shortly. Light and reasonably priced with great surface are.

Check this out. I have a video showing a basic intro to my system. It shows my perlite beds. I use it as a wicking media.

Can I find that on your page, or is there a link I should follow?

RSS

© 2020   Created by Sylvia Bernstein.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service